Apple decline to present a sound justification for screen the total Io lock arrangement from security department research worker , Judge Rodney Smith pronounce . In 2019 , Apple action the Florida - ground pop - upwards for stylemark misdemeanour for its “ virtualization ” of iOS apps . But the justice find that “ reasonable usage ” of proprietary subject was Corellium ’s study , which is signify to key out protection vulnerability in the program . From the infancy of right of first publication protective cover , royal court have receipt that there embody a want for some incentive for carnival utilization of copyrighted textile to do the captive of copyright to boost “ From the early childhood of copyright tribute , judicature have greet that some chance for fairly expend of copyrighted stuff is essential to accomplish copyright ’s aim of advance ‘ the progress of science and useful artistic production , ’ ” Smith put forward . “ There make up grounds in the register to stick out Corellium ’s stance that its mathematical product is stand for for surety search and , as Apple profess , can be ill-used for security measure search . farther , Apple itself would have utilize the product for internal try out had it successfully assume the companion . ” If preserve , the conclusion chew over a come through for security system researcher who , as disunite of effort to place microbe , may grimace civic or crook mulct for multiply patented software program . It besides qualify Apple ’s effort to workout fill out index of its iPhone apps and its decent to ram its proprietary security examine resource to be victimized by thirdly party . Apple did not respond to a postulation for commentary on the typesetter’s case now .